Shocking death of sick man who lost his benefits
Brother tells inquest how ‘perilous’ stress brought on seizures
30 March, 2018 — By Emily Finch
Stephen Braithwaite, died after seizure and fall
A MAN suffering from epilepsy, liver and lung disease who had trouble walking saw his disability benefits withdrawn up until a few months before his death.
Stephen Braithwaite, 59, died at his Canonbury home after taking an accidental overdose of painkillers to cope with broken ribs sustained during a suspected seizure.
His family say he should not have been deemed “fit to work” by the Department for Work and Pensions.
This week, Islington South Labour MP Emily Thornberry, who has campaigned against the government’s welfare reforms, condemned the situation Mr Braithwaite found himself in and warned of the “large holes in Britain’s safety net”.
Mr Braithwaite was an important figure in Islington’s squatting scene in the late 1970s helping house dozens of people.
His younger brother Matthew, 54, told an inquest at St Pancras Coroner’s Court on Monday that his brother had fallen into “major” rent arrears at his council-owned home following the loss of disability benefits before his death in November.
He told the inquest: “The stress could bring on his seizures, as corroborated by his doctor. It was a most perilous situation [he was in]. The stress was palpable.”
Mr Braithwaite had collapsed after suffering a seizure at Jobcentre Plus, in Barnsbury Road, during his weekly “signing on” in August 2016 to receive Job Seeker’s Allowance, which was less than £70 a week.
The inquest heard how Mr Braithwaite suffered from liver disease, epilepsy (following a severe bleed in the brain after a fall in 2012), high blood pressure, mobility issues and chronic lung disease.
He was a recovering drug addict and relied on a walking stick, needing to take frequent breaks when walking.
Stephen’s brothers, Matthew and Chris
His employment and support allowance (ESA), a disability benefit he had received for three years, was stopped two months before he collapsed at the Jobcentre and was only partially reinstated a few months before his death. He had previously worked as an antiques trader in Camden Passage and as a chef in the East End.
Ms Thornberry, whose constituency covers the Jobcentre where Mr Braithwaite collapsed, said: “This is a shocking incident. A mark of a civilised country is how it treats those who are down on their luck. The safety net in Britain has large holes in it through which too many Islington people fall. And it gets worse month after month.
“If people are too sick to work, they should be supported and treated with dignity, not forced to look for a job.”
Matthew Braithwaite told the Tribune after the inquest: “He was told that he had lost his disability benefits on a Saturday afternoon, which stunned him. He was desperately unwell.
“At the Jobcentre they told him they didn’t care about doctor’s certificates and he could still work.
“One of workers told him: ‘Unless you’ve got limbs falling off, and you’re in this office, we think you’re fit for work.’”
Matthew added: “It was all very cynical and callous. The Jobcentre made it so difficult for people to appeal. You have to get it done within a month, which was very overwhelming. I helped him with the appeal and managed to complete it within the month, but they said nothing had changed.”
He said his brother was found fit to work by “healthcare professionals” at the Jobcentre, contracted private workers who decide whether individuals are entitled to disability benefits.
“They are not state registered nurses. How can they decide if people can work? None of them could help him after his seizure and another person signing on had to put him in the recovery position before the paramedics arrived,” said Matthew.
The inquest heard how Stephen was found doubled in pain by his brother after he fell during another suspected seizure at his home in Englefield Road on November 6.
He refused to go to hospital and instead took a series of painkillers. Although Matthew checked on his brother in the night, he found him unresponsive in the morning. Paramedics declared Mr Braithwaite dead at the scene.
A pathology report read out at the inquest said Mr Braithwaite had lethal levels of painkillers in his blood alongside a non-lethal level of heroin. He was also found to have broken ribs from his fall.
Coroner Edwin Buckett gave the cause of death as “drug related” and said Mr Braithwaite had not intended to take his life.
A Department for Work and Pensions spokesman said: “Our thoughts are with Mr Braithwaite’s family. When making a decision for ESA we consider all of the evidence that’s available at the time, including any information provided by the individual and their GP or medical specialist.”